投手和DH,哪一個比較難拿MVP? - 美國職棒

Ida avatar
By Ida
at 2011-11-22T21:12

Table of Contents

先恭喜Justin Verlander,以先發投手的身份拿到今年美聯的MVP。

其實先發投手因為不是每一場都出賽,按照Rotation五天先發一次,
一季不會超過40場先發,再加上又有專為投手設立的賽揚獎,所以要
拿 MVP,真的是除非有壓制力十足的超級數據,才會被「提及」,還
不代表一定會拿,且可能也要看這一季其他野手的競爭者情況而定。

另外就想到一個問題,投手很難拿MVP,那麼專職DH(指定打擊)呢?
記得幾年前,紅襪的老爹David Ortiz有一季傳統的打擊數據很亮眼,
但是當人們談論他獲得MVP的機會時,卻因為他DH的身份,被認為在守
備上沒有貢獻,所以競爭上會吃虧,而那季也不意外的敗陣下來。

(我忘了是06還是07)

這情況是不是跟投手有點像?投手只有投球、守備,打擊貢獻少;而DH
則是不需要守備。MLB歷史上有沒有專職DH拿到MVP的?DH可能會比投手
還要難拿到吧?

不知道版上各位高手的意見如何?

--

All Comments

Isla avatar
By Isla
at 2011-11-24T04:05
強投出場有時候幾乎就是勝利保證,但強打的DH未必就是
Elvira avatar
By Elvira
at 2011-11-27T15:32
所以投手能夠影響戰績應該還是比DH大一些
Hardy avatar
By Hardy
at 2011-12-02T04:31
06年大家都在吵是老爹還是Jeter MVP 結果投票猛牛得XD
Suhail Hany avatar
By Suhail Hany
at 2011-12-03T11:22
大痛有拿過MVP嗎?
Ophelia avatar
By Ophelia
at 2011-12-06T20:14
有 93 94連兩屆MVP
Mary avatar
By Mary
at 2011-12-08T04:59
應該是07??? 記得那年是老爹跟A-ROD都很亮眼
Poppy avatar
By Poppy
at 2011-12-12T09:32
然後事後A-ROD受訪說自己贏在有守位老爹吃虧了
William avatar
By William
at 2011-12-16T15:44
不知道有沒有記錯 有錯請包涵 XD
Belly avatar
By Belly
at 2011-12-19T16:06
可是Bir Hurt當時是一壘手跟DH輪流做,不是純DH
Big
Damian avatar
By Damian
at 2011-12-20T21:35
06年不是Mauer VS Jeter ?
Ida avatar
By Ida
at 2011-12-25T19:32
其實那兩年Big Hurt打DH才打17場就是:P。
Hedda avatar
By Hedda
at 2011-12-26T10:37
查了一下資料 自引進DH制度以來並沒有任何的專職DH拿過MVP
Kama avatar
By Kama
at 2011-12-27T07:24
查到1999的Pedro還是贏不了IVAN 捕手砲真那麼稀有??
Elvira avatar
By Elvira
at 2011-12-29T08:03
捕手砲是非常稀有吧 而且大管的捕手砲 通常守備都差
Lily avatar
By Lily
at 2011-12-30T06:59
I-Rod那年 打守兼備 拿MVP 我個人覺得不過分
Caitlin avatar
By Caitlin
at 2012-01-01T18:38
Dh 60 hr 130分打點 勝利打點15場這樣有機會嗎
Oliver avatar
By Oliver
at 2012-01-06T00:11
Pedro那年確實很可惜,所以真的投手要拿也要有點機運
Kumar avatar
By Kumar
at 2012-01-09T02:47
變態打者+變態守位(C=SS>2B) 是這樣嗎?
Hedwig avatar
By Hedwig
at 2012-01-09T17:48
Don Baylor (1979) OF*97 DH*65 這算DH比重高的
Sierra Rose avatar
By Sierra Rose
at 2012-01-13T19:53
感謝a大 守備數據有點難懂XD
Delia avatar
By Delia
at 2012-01-14T23:51
jack0124:Dh 60 hr 130分打點,當今連第4棒都沒60HR了
真的打得出來MVP機會應該是9成
Andrew avatar
By Andrew
at 2012-01-15T23:05
Ryan Howard 06年58Hr 149RBI .313/.425/.659
如果是在美聯DH打這種成績不知道有沒有機會
Aaliyah avatar
By Aaliyah
at 2012-01-16T09:04
還是要看當年的競爭對手吧!
James avatar
By James
at 2012-01-19T13:29
05也是啊
Genevieve avatar
By Genevieve
at 2012-01-23T09:47
Albert Pujols:生涯太平均也很苦惱~
Edward Lewis avatar
By Edward Lewis
at 2012-01-25T00:22
72 HR or 200BB 這樣DH應該會拿MVP
Quintina avatar
By Quintina
at 2012-01-26T11:28
比較想知道除了老爹外有"純DH"的嗎!?
Vanessa avatar
By Vanessa
at 2012-01-30T18:32
Travis Hafner
Wallis avatar
By Wallis
at 2012-02-01T10:32
Thome大叔算嗎?
Jessica avatar
By Jessica
at 2012-02-06T00:04
DH成績好到逆天就輕鬆拿囉 來個BA.450 HR70 OPS+250 不拿都難
Noah avatar
By Noah
at 2012-02-08T13:00
BA.45歷史上有誰達到過(一定打數 ex: G*3.1)??
Dinah avatar
By Dinah
at 2012-02-09T11:54
BA .45 HR70 的話, 我連賽揚都投給他
Frederic avatar
By Frederic
at 2012-02-10T02:15
有人.492耶XDDDDD 不過是上古人士就是了
Elvira avatar
By Elvira
at 2012-02-13T22:37
強投出手就是勝利保證? Felix表示:
Edward Lewis avatar
By Edward Lewis
at 2012-02-18T18:02
一樓一看就是外行,去看看今年V中年勝率多少吧
Andrew avatar
By Andrew
at 2012-02-21T13:08
再來退一萬步來說,本文就在討論強投只能五天上來給一次保證
Sarah avatar
By Sarah
at 2012-02-25T09:51
只要*那年的棒子爺打DH,不給他MVP都難,否則MVP可以廢了
Enid avatar
By Enid
at 2012-02-26T20:40
那如果一個守備超爛跟專職DH比勒? 守備會不會成為落選因素?
Olivia avatar
By Olivia
at 2012-02-28T10:52
大概不會
Elvira avatar
By Elvira
at 2012-03-02T05:07
差不多的成績有守備位置的打者拿MVP的機會當然大的多
Ursula avatar
By Ursula
at 2012-03-04T05:43
從選手對球隊戰績影響程度來看 比較實在吧
尤其是關鍵比賽

終結者洗牌同盟

Madame avatar
By Madame
at 2011-11-22T10:23
目前仍未確定Closer的隊伍: BlueJays、RedSox、Twins、Marlins、Padres、Mets、Reds FA Closers: Heath Bell (34) - Type A Jonathan Broxton (28) Matt Capps ...

Rangers To Sign Joe Nathan

Carolina Franco avatar
By Carolina Franco
at 2011-11-22T09:14
http://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2011/11/rangers-to-sign-joe-nathan-.html The Rangers have signed Joe Nathan, according to T.R. Sullivan of MLB.com. Itand#39 ...

鄭大炫

Noah avatar
By Noah
at 2011-11-22T09:05
http://tinyurl.com/79tujcm Meanwhile, the Orioles apparently are close to signing Korean reliever Chong Tae-Hyon, who turns 33 in December, but itand#39;s ...

AL MVP

Gary avatar
By Gary
at 2011-11-22T03:41
1st 2nd 3rd 4th 5th 6th 7th 8th 9th 10th Points Justin Verlander Detroit Tigers 13 3 3 4 1 2 1 280 Jacoby Ellsbury Boston Re ...

Justin Verlander Wins AL MVP

Hedda avatar
By Hedda
at 2011-11-22T03:06
Justin Verlander won the American League MVP award, according to the Baseball Writers Association of America. Verlander took home the ALand#39;s Cy Young ...