對於大滿貫懲處委員會的疑慮 - 網球 Tennis

By Selena
at 2011-06-19T21:05
at 2011-06-19T21:05
Table of Contents
之前在這個版測試過言論自由的底線三次
第一次被認可為言論自由的範圍;第二和第三次被認定引戰被桶
最候一次的違規判定是透過大滿貫懲處委員會投票表決的
但我希望大家思考所謂的"透過委員會投票,板主群裁判"兩階段審核的問題
在於言論自由底線的一致性
換言之,撇開那種明顯強烈引戰的違規言論
遊走在規定邊緣的言論是有可能會因為球迷心態做祟
而導致委員會在針對不同球員的同一句評論有不同的投票結果
(舉例:對費或對小威的負面評論比較嚴格,但是以類似的話評論其他球員就沒事)
說穿了~委員會投票制的公正性還是會受到特定球迷多寡的影響
(但的確至少比萬一板主剛好是某迷的情況好一點)
雖然說負起最終責任的是板主群,
但延伸而出的就是委員會投票不必負責,以及如何確保判決標準具一致性的問題
--
第一次被認可為言論自由的範圍;第二和第三次被認定引戰被桶
最候一次的違規判定是透過大滿貫懲處委員會投票表決的
但我希望大家思考所謂的"透過委員會投票,板主群裁判"兩階段審核的問題
在於言論自由底線的一致性
換言之,撇開那種明顯強烈引戰的違規言論
遊走在規定邊緣的言論是有可能會因為球迷心態做祟
而導致委員會在針對不同球員的同一句評論有不同的投票結果
(舉例:對費或對小威的負面評論比較嚴格,但是以類似的話評論其他球員就沒事)
說穿了~委員會投票制的公正性還是會受到特定球迷多寡的影響
(但的確至少比萬一板主剛好是某迷的情況好一點)
雖然說負起最終責任的是板主群,
但延伸而出的就是委員會投票不必負責,以及如何確保判決標準具一致性的問題
--
Tags:
網球
All Comments

By Robert
at 2011-06-21T13:22
at 2011-06-21T13:22

By Carolina Franco
at 2011-06-23T05:39
at 2011-06-23T05:39

By Aaliyah
at 2011-06-24T21:56
at 2011-06-24T21:56

By Gilbert
at 2011-06-26T14:13
at 2011-06-26T14:13

By Tracy
at 2011-06-28T06:30
at 2011-06-28T06:30

By Aaliyah
at 2011-06-29T22:47
at 2011-06-29T22:47

By Isla
at 2011-07-01T15:04
at 2011-07-01T15:04

By Candice
at 2011-07-03T07:21
at 2011-07-03T07:21

By Edith
at 2011-07-04T23:38
at 2011-07-04T23:38

By Skylar Davis
at 2011-07-06T15:55
at 2011-07-06T15:55

By Selena
at 2011-07-08T08:12
at 2011-07-08T08:12

By Jessica
at 2011-07-10T00:30
at 2011-07-10T00:30

By Candice
at 2011-07-11T16:47
at 2011-07-11T16:47

By Caroline
at 2011-07-13T09:04
at 2011-07-13T09:04

By Kristin
at 2011-07-15T01:21
at 2011-07-15T01:21

By Necoo
at 2011-07-16T17:38
at 2011-07-16T17:38

By Susan
at 2011-07-18T09:55
at 2011-07-18T09:55

By Ivy
at 2011-07-20T02:12
at 2011-07-20T02:12

By Mia
at 2011-07-21T18:29
at 2011-07-21T18:29

By Suhail Hany
at 2011-07-23T10:46
at 2011-07-23T10:46

By Genevieve
at 2011-07-25T03:03
at 2011-07-25T03:03

By Mason
at 2011-07-26T19:20
at 2011-07-26T19:20

By Michael
at 2011-07-28T11:37
at 2011-07-28T11:37

By Annie
at 2011-07-30T03:54
at 2011-07-30T03:54

By Mary
at 2011-07-31T20:11
at 2011-07-31T20:11

By Rachel
at 2011-08-02T12:28
at 2011-08-02T12:28

By Caroline
at 2011-08-04T04:46
at 2011-08-04T04:46

By Mason
at 2011-08-05T21:03
at 2011-08-05T21:03

By Leila
at 2011-08-07T13:20
at 2011-08-07T13:20

By Kristin
at 2011-08-09T05:37
at 2011-08-09T05:37

By Selena
at 2011-08-10T21:54
at 2011-08-10T21:54

By Michael
at 2011-08-12T14:11
at 2011-08-12T14:11

By Gilbert
at 2011-08-14T06:28
at 2011-08-14T06:28

By Ina
at 2011-08-15T22:45
at 2011-08-15T22:45

By Zora
at 2011-08-17T15:02
at 2011-08-17T15:02

By Barb Cronin
at 2011-08-19T07:19
at 2011-08-19T07:19

By Dorothy
at 2011-08-20T23:36
at 2011-08-20T23:36

By Selena
at 2011-08-22T15:53
at 2011-08-22T15:53

By Elma
at 2011-08-24T08:10
at 2011-08-24T08:10

By Rebecca
at 2011-08-26T00:27
at 2011-08-26T00:27

By Donna
at 2011-08-27T16:44
at 2011-08-27T16:44

By Sandy
at 2011-08-29T09:02
at 2011-08-29T09:02

By Ophelia
at 2011-08-31T01:19
at 2011-08-31T01:19

By Ingrid
at 2011-09-01T17:36
at 2011-09-01T17:36

By Zenobia
at 2011-09-03T09:53
at 2011-09-03T09:53

By Edward Lewis
at 2011-09-05T02:10
at 2011-09-05T02:10

By Ida
at 2011-09-06T18:27
at 2011-09-06T18:27

By Suhail Hany
at 2011-09-08T10:44
at 2011-09-08T10:44

By Dora
at 2011-09-10T03:01
at 2011-09-10T03:01

By Frederic
at 2011-09-11T19:18
at 2011-09-11T19:18

By Emily
at 2011-09-13T11:35
at 2011-09-13T11:35

By Megan
at 2011-09-15T03:52
at 2011-09-15T03:52

By Audriana
at 2011-09-16T20:09
at 2011-09-16T20:09

By Zora
at 2011-09-18T12:26
at 2011-09-18T12:26

By Leila
at 2011-09-20T04:43
at 2011-09-20T04:43

By Liam
at 2011-09-21T21:00
at 2011-09-21T21:00

By Liam
at 2011-09-23T13:18
at 2011-09-23T13:18

By Jack
at 2011-09-25T05:35
at 2011-09-25T05:35

By Agatha
at 2011-09-26T21:52
at 2011-09-26T21:52

By Isabella
at 2011-09-28T14:09
at 2011-09-28T14:09

By Zanna
at 2011-09-30T06:26
at 2011-09-30T06:26

By Gilbert
at 2011-10-01T22:43
at 2011-10-01T22:43

By Robert
at 2011-10-03T15:00
at 2011-10-03T15:00

By Callum
at 2011-10-05T07:17
at 2011-10-05T07:17

By Freda
at 2011-10-06T23:34
at 2011-10-06T23:34

By Donna
at 2011-10-08T15:51
at 2011-10-08T15:51
Related Posts
2011溫網會內賽 - 06/20 - 凱貞S-1R

By Jessica
at 2011-06-19T19:24
at 2011-06-19T19:24
===== 本週排名 11/06/20 =====

By Harry
at 2011-06-19T14:27
at 2011-06-19T14:27
小威回歸更加突顯女網尷尬 老將當道新星不振引人憂

By Zenobia
at 2011-06-19T13:58
at 2011-06-19T13:58
非美國運動員 費德勒吸金最多

By Ursula
at 2011-06-19T11:40
at 2011-06-19T11:40
ATP 6/18賽果

By Anonymous
at 2011-06-19T07:52
at 2011-06-19T07:52