包容誤判和假摔的病態感 - 世足

By Quanna
at 2010-06-28T03:14
at 2010-06-28T03:14
Table of Contents
老實說我是一月球迷,以下是由外行人的觀點提出的問題,
請各位先進手下留情別砲得太大力謝謝~~.~>
今天德國以4:[1(+1)]大勝,以在下個人而言真的看得很不爽,
也想對這裡個禮拜來看到足球的"容錯率"感到相當驚訝和不解。
像以今天來說的話,追平的那球被裁判吃掉真的差太多了,
如果當初判決是2:2的話,想來必定會影響後來戰局的發展!
當然也可從這件事看出,足球判決其實是常與科學互相牴觸、
卻又更常不願面對真相的一件鴕鳥差事,
像今天那球擺明就是裁判追不上球的速度,
最後只好"下"(還是"猜"?!)一個判斷說球沒進的詭譎現象。
如果這在過去攝影技術還不發達的時代還說得過去,
不過現今比賽場地根本隨時架著20來台攝影機作即時全球轉播和慢動作重播,
明明3分鐘內就可以確定的判決,卻還要應是裁判回去寫判決悔過書,
然後接受一個根本不是事實的結果。
雖說用其他運動比賽來比擬並不完全適合,但僅從實事求是的比賽公正性去看,
例如在當今棒球判斷全壘打出界與否已可調閱影片重判、
網球出界能以精準測量的鷹眼作次數挑戰的邏輯看來,
足球似乎還停在一種墨守成規的原始判決裡,想來實在是令人在在想不太透。
明明是國際級的賽事,卻硬是要全世界的人跟裁判一起瞎了眼,
然後再來亡羊補牢,這種感覺真的超級不好的。
或許會有人想說上一句話給像我這樣的一月球迷,也就是說:"這就是規定。"
不過規則分明也是可以改的,不該是釘死在那裡卻又跟邏輯自打嘴巴的吧?
再回想起這些日子以來,重播畫面裡眾位球星你撞過來我飛出去、
你打胸口我摀顏面的紙片人模樣....就更加令人對整個足球比賽的生態感到困惑....
若是更改規定可以讓比賽變得更公正更科學,
那為何"公平公正公開的賽事",卻還是硬要承受人類的劣根性和裁判體能極限?
那為何還要耗費此多資源架上眾台攝影機,
讓觀眾好一飽眼福觀看球賽、還可順便一窺現場"貨真價實"的實況轉播?
為何大家都得承受這個FIFA亡羊卻不太願意補牢的做法?
當然裁判也是人、球員也想偷吃步的心態是在所難免,
但面對誇張或惡性重大的造假動作,乃至對比賽具有絕對影響(如得失分)的判決方面,
是不是該有更大彈性的容錯更正性才行?
或許這樣也可避免掉許多事後的忿懣和指責,
以期足球比賽變得比較"科學客觀"且"人性光明"一點的吧。
不知道眾位的想法又是如何,若能給在下一些指引和意見討論,
著實是相當歡迎且感激~:)
--
最後就祝 各位版友這幾天看球愉快了~@ @">
--
善も惡も、生も死も超えたとこそを、淡々と歩いてきた。 幸も不幸も無い。
喜びも悲しみも無い。 白と黒が私を切り裂いて、天と地が私を嬲って、
私は淫らになってしまった。 私はどこにも屬さない。私は歩んではいないのだ。
ただ、世界が回っていた。 私の知らないどころで、世界だけが
ならば─それでいい。
世界はいつだって、私のために回っているのだから。 《空の軌跡3rd‧星の扉15》レン
--
請各位先進手下留情別砲得太大力謝謝~~.~>
今天德國以4:[1(+1)]大勝,以在下個人而言真的看得很不爽,
也想對這裡個禮拜來看到足球的"容錯率"感到相當驚訝和不解。
像以今天來說的話,追平的那球被裁判吃掉真的差太多了,
如果當初判決是2:2的話,想來必定會影響後來戰局的發展!
當然也可從這件事看出,足球判決其實是常與科學互相牴觸、
卻又更常不願面對真相的一件鴕鳥差事,
像今天那球擺明就是裁判追不上球的速度,
最後只好"下"(還是"猜"?!)一個判斷說球沒進的詭譎現象。
如果這在過去攝影技術還不發達的時代還說得過去,
不過現今比賽場地根本隨時架著20來台攝影機作即時全球轉播和慢動作重播,
明明3分鐘內就可以確定的判決,卻還要應是裁判回去寫判決悔過書,
然後接受一個根本不是事實的結果。
雖說用其他運動比賽來比擬並不完全適合,但僅從實事求是的比賽公正性去看,
例如在當今棒球判斷全壘打出界與否已可調閱影片重判、
網球出界能以精準測量的鷹眼作次數挑戰的邏輯看來,
足球似乎還停在一種墨守成規的原始判決裡,想來實在是令人在在想不太透。
明明是國際級的賽事,卻硬是要全世界的人跟裁判一起瞎了眼,
然後再來亡羊補牢,這種感覺真的超級不好的。
或許會有人想說上一句話給像我這樣的一月球迷,也就是說:"這就是規定。"
不過規則分明也是可以改的,不該是釘死在那裡卻又跟邏輯自打嘴巴的吧?
再回想起這些日子以來,重播畫面裡眾位球星你撞過來我飛出去、
你打胸口我摀顏面的紙片人模樣....就更加令人對整個足球比賽的生態感到困惑....
若是更改規定可以讓比賽變得更公正更科學,
那為何"公平公正公開的賽事",卻還是硬要承受人類的劣根性和裁判體能極限?
那為何還要耗費此多資源架上眾台攝影機,
讓觀眾好一飽眼福觀看球賽、還可順便一窺現場"貨真價實"的實況轉播?
為何大家都得承受這個FIFA亡羊卻不太願意補牢的做法?
當然裁判也是人、球員也想偷吃步的心態是在所難免,
但面對誇張或惡性重大的造假動作,乃至對比賽具有絕對影響(如得失分)的判決方面,
是不是該有更大彈性的容錯更正性才行?
或許這樣也可避免掉許多事後的忿懣和指責,
以期足球比賽變得比較"科學客觀"且"人性光明"一點的吧。
不知道眾位的想法又是如何,若能給在下一些指引和意見討論,
著實是相當歡迎且感激~:)
--
最後就祝 各位版友這幾天看球愉快了~@ @">
--
善も惡も、生も死も超えたとこそを、淡々と歩いてきた。 幸も不幸も無い。
喜びも悲しみも無い。 白と黒が私を切り裂いて、天と地が私を嬲って、
私は淫らになってしまった。 私はどこにも屬さない。私は歩んではいないのだ。
ただ、世界が回っていた。 私の知らないどころで、世界だけが
ならば─それでいい。
世界はいつだって、私のために回っているのだから。 《空の軌跡3rd‧星の扉15》レン
--
Tags:
世足
All Comments

By Sierra Rose
at 2010-07-02T23:44
at 2010-07-02T23:44

By William
at 2010-07-05T13:29
at 2010-07-05T13:29

By Genevieve
at 2010-07-09T01:59
at 2010-07-09T01:59

By Olive
at 2010-07-10T14:49
at 2010-07-10T14:49

By Edith
at 2010-07-13T07:00
at 2010-07-13T07:00

By Tom
at 2010-07-16T22:06
at 2010-07-16T22:06

By Oscar
at 2010-07-19T07:14
at 2010-07-19T07:14

By Lauren
at 2010-07-21T14:08
at 2010-07-21T14:08

By Anthony
at 2010-07-21T15:59
at 2010-07-21T15:59

By Mia
at 2010-07-26T01:54
at 2010-07-26T01:54

By Joe
at 2010-07-29T00:00
at 2010-07-29T00:00

By Yuri
at 2010-07-30T01:43
at 2010-07-30T01:43

By Catherine
at 2010-07-31T15:49
at 2010-07-31T15:49

By Yuri
at 2010-08-04T20:15
at 2010-08-04T20:15

By Hedy
at 2010-08-08T07:16
at 2010-08-08T07:16

By Sierra Rose
at 2010-08-10T06:23
at 2010-08-10T06:23

By Eden
at 2010-08-12T12:22
at 2010-08-12T12:22

By Leila
at 2010-08-15T20:22
at 2010-08-15T20:22

By Agatha
at 2010-08-19T00:52
at 2010-08-19T00:52

By Tristan Cohan
at 2010-08-20T02:04
at 2010-08-20T02:04

By Ursula
at 2010-08-21T13:56
at 2010-08-21T13:56

By Poppy
at 2010-08-21T17:51
at 2010-08-21T17:51

By Connor
at 2010-08-24T03:45
at 2010-08-24T03:45

By Connor
at 2010-08-25T17:00
at 2010-08-25T17:00

By Hedwig
at 2010-08-28T12:38
at 2010-08-28T12:38

By Skylar DavisLinda
at 2010-09-01T10:46
at 2010-09-01T10:46

By Rebecca
at 2010-09-04T06:39
at 2010-09-04T06:39

By George
at 2010-09-06T21:37
at 2010-09-06T21:37

By Sandy
at 2010-09-11T04:11
at 2010-09-11T04:11

By Aaliyah
at 2010-09-14T12:02
at 2010-09-14T12:02

By Rebecca
at 2010-09-19T06:42
at 2010-09-19T06:42

By Belly
at 2010-09-21T13:29
at 2010-09-21T13:29

By Kristin
at 2010-09-23T00:38
at 2010-09-23T00:38

By Robert
at 2010-09-23T05:33
at 2010-09-23T05:33

By Puput
at 2010-09-24T15:31
at 2010-09-24T15:31

By Gary
at 2010-09-27T09:37
at 2010-09-27T09:37

By Yedda
at 2010-09-30T08:01
at 2010-09-30T08:01

By Linda
at 2010-10-02T00:04
at 2010-10-02T00:04

By Jake
at 2010-10-04T14:40
at 2010-10-04T14:40

By Tristan Cohan
at 2010-10-06T06:15
at 2010-10-06T06:15

By Suhail Hany
at 2010-10-08T09:53
at 2010-10-08T09:53

By Cara
at 2010-10-09T08:36
at 2010-10-09T08:36

By Yuri
at 2010-10-12T23:42
at 2010-10-12T23:42

By Dora
at 2010-10-16T01:40
at 2010-10-16T01:40

By Regina
at 2010-10-18T00:57
at 2010-10-18T00:57

By Edith
at 2010-10-18T19:51
at 2010-10-18T19:51

By Aaliyah
at 2010-10-23T02:09
at 2010-10-23T02:09

By Charlotte
at 2010-10-27T10:01
at 2010-10-27T10:01

By Ivy
at 2010-10-29T04:40
at 2010-10-29T04:40

By Elizabeth
at 2010-10-31T23:42
at 2010-10-31T23:42

By Una
at 2010-11-01T00:52
at 2010-11-01T00:52

By Delia
at 2010-11-01T02:46
at 2010-11-01T02:46

By Hedy
at 2010-11-03T00:29
at 2010-11-03T00:29

By Leila
at 2010-11-03T16:10
at 2010-11-03T16:10

By Edward Lewis
at 2010-11-04T20:24
at 2010-11-04T20:24

By Queena
at 2010-11-05T13:31
at 2010-11-05T13:31

By Edward Lewis
at 2010-11-06T18:43
at 2010-11-06T18:43

By Carolina Franco
at 2010-11-11T15:50
at 2010-11-11T15:50

By Emily
at 2010-11-15T07:48
at 2010-11-15T07:48

By Todd Johnson
at 2010-11-16T08:37
at 2010-11-16T08:37

By Bethany
at 2010-11-20T12:32
at 2010-11-20T12:32

By Hamiltion
at 2010-11-21T07:10
at 2010-11-21T07:10

By Regina
at 2010-11-21T18:37
at 2010-11-21T18:37

By Edward Lewis
at 2010-11-22T22:56
at 2010-11-22T22:56

By Daniel
at 2010-11-23T20:40
at 2010-11-23T20:40

By Skylar DavisLinda
at 2010-11-28T06:12
at 2010-11-28T06:12

By Damian
at 2010-12-02T15:12
at 2010-12-02T15:12

By Susan
at 2010-12-06T03:17
at 2010-12-06T03:17

By Callum
at 2010-12-08T18:11
at 2010-12-08T18:11

By Rae
at 2010-12-10T17:56
at 2010-12-10T17:56

By Xanthe
at 2010-12-15T15:51
at 2010-12-15T15:51

By Rae
at 2010-12-20T10:44
at 2010-12-20T10:44

By Kama
at 2010-12-22T01:13
at 2010-12-22T01:13

By Damian
at 2010-12-26T05:06
at 2010-12-26T05:06

By Xanthe
at 2010-12-29T22:02
at 2010-12-29T22:02

By Olive
at 2010-12-31T19:37
at 2010-12-31T19:37

By Tom
at 2011-01-03T19:39
at 2011-01-03T19:39

By Donna
at 2011-01-07T02:11
at 2011-01-07T02:11

By Gary
at 2011-01-08T08:21
at 2011-01-08T08:21

By Oscar
at 2011-01-09T15:55
at 2011-01-09T15:55

By Kama
at 2011-01-13T16:17
at 2011-01-13T16:17

By Sierra Rose
at 2011-01-16T22:02
at 2011-01-16T22:02

By Lydia
at 2011-01-21T21:10
at 2011-01-21T21:10

By Annie
at 2011-01-25T07:22
at 2011-01-25T07:22

By Edward Lewis
at 2011-01-29T06:27
at 2011-01-29T06:27

By Suhail Hany
at 2011-01-31T23:42
at 2011-01-31T23:42

By Necoo
at 2011-02-03T03:27
at 2011-02-03T03:27

By Liam
at 2011-02-03T20:54
at 2011-02-03T20:54

By Hedy
at 2011-02-08T16:54
at 2011-02-08T16:54

By Poppy
at 2011-02-10T23:21
at 2011-02-10T23:21

By Elizabeth
at 2011-02-13T00:09
at 2011-02-13T00:09

By Heather
at 2011-02-14T07:54
at 2011-02-14T07:54

By Bethany
at 2011-02-16T13:08
at 2011-02-16T13:08

By Suhail Hany
at 2011-02-20T19:47
at 2011-02-20T19:47

By Connor
at 2011-02-25T04:49
at 2011-02-25T04:49

By Belly
at 2011-02-27T02:59
at 2011-02-27T02:59

By Steve
at 2011-03-01T02:53
at 2011-03-01T02:53

By Elvira
at 2011-03-03T21:41
at 2011-03-03T21:41

By Hedwig
at 2011-03-05T13:58
at 2011-03-05T13:58

By John
at 2011-03-09T00:22
at 2011-03-09T00:22

By Tristan Cohan
at 2011-03-09T22:49
at 2011-03-09T22:49

By Leila
at 2011-03-11T13:03
at 2011-03-11T13:03

By Emma
at 2011-03-15T19:21
at 2011-03-15T19:21

By Necoo
at 2011-03-16T10:05
at 2011-03-16T10:05

By Audriana
at 2011-03-18T07:21
at 2011-03-18T07:21

By Isabella
at 2011-03-22T19:17
at 2011-03-22T19:17

By Quanna
at 2011-03-25T21:19
at 2011-03-25T21:19

By Quanna
at 2011-03-30T06:34
at 2011-03-30T06:34

By Zanna
at 2011-04-01T06:39
at 2011-04-01T06:39

By Ida
at 2011-04-04T13:03
at 2011-04-04T13:03

By Sierra Rose
at 2011-04-08T07:33
at 2011-04-08T07:33

By Belly
at 2011-04-12T10:33
at 2011-04-12T10:33

By Gary
at 2011-04-17T09:52
at 2011-04-17T09:52

By Rachel
at 2011-04-19T13:47
at 2011-04-19T13:47

By Rae
at 2011-04-22T10:02
at 2011-04-22T10:02

By Harry
at 2011-04-23T10:30
at 2011-04-23T10:30

By Tristan Cohan
at 2011-04-25T03:35
at 2011-04-25T03:35

By Mary
at 2011-04-27T14:56
at 2011-04-27T14:56

By Joseph
at 2011-04-30T22:15
at 2011-04-30T22:15

By Frederic
at 2011-05-05T09:04
at 2011-05-05T09:04

By Genevieve
at 2011-05-06T03:26
at 2011-05-06T03:26

By Gilbert
at 2011-05-08T09:33
at 2011-05-08T09:33

By Hedda
at 2011-05-09T06:28
at 2011-05-09T06:28

By Cara
at 2011-05-09T22:50
at 2011-05-09T22:50

By Heather
at 2011-05-12T23:27
at 2011-05-12T23:27

By Rachel
at 2011-05-15T20:46
at 2011-05-15T20:46

By Dorothy
at 2011-05-17T08:05
at 2011-05-17T08:05

By Joe
at 2011-05-19T22:49
at 2011-05-19T22:49

By Ethan
at 2011-05-23T15:09
at 2011-05-23T15:09

By Callum
at 2011-05-24T09:30
at 2011-05-24T09:30

By Kumar
at 2011-05-27T10:01
at 2011-05-27T10:01

By Elizabeth
at 2011-05-28T21:21
at 2011-05-28T21:21

By Hazel
at 2011-05-30T15:41
at 2011-05-30T15:41

By Joe
at 2011-05-30T23:41
at 2011-05-30T23:41

By Adele
at 2011-06-02T09:13
at 2011-06-02T09:13

By Jake
at 2011-06-03T18:13
at 2011-06-03T18:13

By Hamiltion
at 2011-06-05T05:39
at 2011-06-05T05:39

By Lucy
at 2011-06-05T17:18
at 2011-06-05T17:18

By Ula
at 2011-06-09T16:29
at 2011-06-09T16:29

By Tristan Cohan
at 2011-06-11T14:00
at 2011-06-11T14:00

By Rae
at 2011-06-13T23:30
at 2011-06-13T23:30

By Linda
at 2011-06-18T14:49
at 2011-06-18T14:49

By Quintina
at 2011-06-19T10:09
at 2011-06-19T10:09

By Bennie
at 2011-06-20T19:50
at 2011-06-20T19:50

By Wallis
at 2011-06-22T23:01
at 2011-06-22T23:01

By Robert
at 2011-06-26T20:01
at 2011-06-26T20:01

By Aaliyah
at 2011-07-01T12:06
at 2011-07-01T12:06

By Ina
at 2011-07-04T05:52
at 2011-07-04T05:52

By Adele
at 2011-07-05T05:41
at 2011-07-05T05:41

By Thomas
at 2011-07-07T04:14
at 2011-07-07T04:14

By Gary
at 2011-07-09T00:38
at 2011-07-09T00:38

By Ethan
at 2011-07-10T03:03
at 2011-07-10T03:03
Related Posts
Re: 這誤判影響可大了

By Charlie
at 2010-06-28T03:12
at 2010-06-28T03:12
Re: 這誤判影響可大了

By Skylar Davis
at 2010-06-28T03:10
at 2010-06-28T03:10
一場球賽內 一個球員拿到第三張黃牌才出場

By Michael
at 2010-06-28T03:10
at 2010-06-28T03:10
請問有沒有球員抓狂揍裁判的?

By Jacob
at 2010-06-28T03:08
at 2010-06-28T03:08
這誤判影響可大了

By Suhail Hany
at 2010-06-28T03:08
at 2010-06-28T03:08