Do referees favour Barcelona in Europe? - 巴塞隆納足球俱樂部 Futbol Club Barcelona

Michael avatar
By Michael
at 2011-03-10T21:21

Table of Contents

http://eircomsports.eircom.net/News/Barca-European-decisions.aspx

Out of 15 'borderline' decisions in knock-out games under Pep
Guardiola, seven went for Barcelona and eight went against.


After Robin van Persie’s ridiculous red card last night, there has
been an element of debate over whether referees “favour” Barcelona
in Europe. In the Daily Mail today Martin Samuel wrote “it would make
a refreshing change if just once Barcelona could win this tournament
without being set on their way by the obliging incompetence of a match
official. For the clueless Tom Henning Ovrebo against Chelsea in 2009,
read the merciless Massimo Busacca in 2011.”

To some, particularly Arsene Wenger, the outcome would have been
markedly different had Van Persie stayed on the pitch. However,
the outcome could also have been markedly different had Leo Messi’s
marginal offside call in the first leg been allowed or the same player
been awarded a penalty before half-time.

Mindful of this counter-balance as well as the copious conspiracy theories
around referees and Uefa, we decided to look at all of the marginal calls
involved in Barcelona’s Champions League knock-out games under Pep
Guardiola. The point was not to express judgment on any of them, merely
to lay them out and say whether they went for or against Barcelona.

As ever, it appears accusations of bias on either side are illusory.
The marginal calls generally even out.



Barcelona 0-0 Chelsea, 2009 SF

Against Barcelona 0-1

Jose Bosingwa grabs Thierry Henry in the box. Penalty appeal turned down.



Chelsea 1-1 Barcelona, 2009 SF

For Barcelona 1-1

Dani Alves tugs Florent Malouda who falls around edge of box.
Ref rules outside.



Chelsea 1-1 Barcelona, 2009 SF

For Barcelona 2-1

Eric Abidal tugs Didier Drogba’s shirt as the striker goes
through on goal. No penalty or red card.



Chelsea 1-1 Barcelona, 2009 SF

Against Barcelona 2-2

Aric Abidal sent off for colliding with Nicolas Anelka.



Chelsea 1-1 Barcelona, 2009 SF

For Barcelona 3-2

Ball hits Gerard Pique’s hand in the box. No penalty given.



Chelsea 1-1 Barcelona, 2009 SF

For Barcelona 4-2

Ball hits Seydou Keita’s arm in the box. No penalty given.



Arsenal 2-2 Barcelona, 2010 QF

Against Barcelona 4-3

Carlos Puyol and Cesc Fabregas collide. Penalty given, Puyol sent off



Inter 3-1 Barcelona, 2010 SF

For Barcelona 5-3

Samuel Eto’o in through on goal only to be called for offside in
borderline decision.



Inter 3-1 Barcelona, 2010 SF

Against Barcelona 5-4

Milito in offside position when Sneijder takes preceding touch.
Scores and goal given.



Inter 3-1 Barcelona, 2010 SF

Against Barcelona 5-5

Wesley Sneijder brings down Dani Alves in the box. Alves booked for diving.



Barcelona 1-0 Inter, 2010 SF

For Barcelona 6-5

Sergio Busquets goes down after Thiago Motta palms face.
Notoriously peeks at referee. Motta is sent off.



Barcelona 1-0 Inter, 2010 SF

Against Barcelona 6-6

Bojan Krkic scores but goal disallowed because ball struck Yaya
Toure’s arm. Debate over “ball to hand” ensues.



Arsenal 2-1 Barcelona, 2011 last-16

Against Barcelona 6-7

Leo Messi scores but goal disallowed for offside. Replays suggest
it was onside.



Barcelona 3-1 Arsenal, 2011 last-16

Against Barcelona 6-8

Leo Messi brought down on edge of box. Penalty not given.



Barcelona 3-1 Arsenal, 2011 last-16

For Barcelona 7-8

Robin Van Persie given second booking for shooting after whistle had blown.

--

from a fan:

how many times have we seen forwards shown yellow cards for kicking
the ball after the whistle is blown? standard stuff. so what’s the
difference here? the game does not (and should not) make exceptions
for english teams, managers, or fans. All teams in all competitions
suffer or benefit from referring decisions from time to time.
how come it’s only made a huge issue when english clubs suffer
from such decisions?

--



Massimo Busacca 真是個爛裁判沒錯,尤其是這兩個判決:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lphanLlEsrs

http://www.dailymotion.com/video/xhgg1n_barcapensht57_travel


--
Tags: 足球

All Comments

Olivia avatar
By Olivia
at 2011-03-13T09:54
人都只會放大自己想看到的東西,不想看到的就無視這樣
Irma avatar
By Irma
at 2011-03-15T22:27
梅西那個在邊上被踢到的那球 還剛好是在他眼前發生的..=.=
Margaret avatar
By Margaret
at 2011-03-18T11:00
推!!!!!!!!
Daniel avatar
By Daniel
at 2011-03-20T23:34
這種比賽一般都會怪裁判 只有我們的對手會酸乾爹XD
Edward Lewis avatar
By Edward Lewis
at 2011-03-23T12:07
1.禁區跨下剪刀夾對方的射門腳 2.球離開人 人才倒
Ingrid avatar
By Ingrid
at 2011-03-26T00:40
大師連這裡也要來開釋
Rosalind avatar
By Rosalind
at 2011-03-28T13:13
原來被人家腳卡到重要部位時還要劈腿才能證明沒犯規嗎
Selena avatar
By Selena
at 2011-03-31T01:46
P大 我想你寶貴的時間不該花在對牛彈琴上 =]
Ingrid avatar
By Ingrid
at 2011-04-02T14:19
天知道我有多希望RVP沒被罰下場,得益於裁判或被迫害,
Ingrid avatar
By Ingrid
at 2011-04-05T02:52
每隊都遇過好嗎?既然巴薩球迷都活在自己世界,
就請不要來這裡打醒我們了。
Noah avatar
By Noah
at 2011-04-07T15:25
給樓上:如果RVP沒被罰下場,我們贏了還是會被酸乾爹
Hazel avatar
By Hazel
at 2011-04-10T03:58
因為D2還是剪刀腳 XXX還是怎樣XXX沒被判牌XXX越位
所以結論就是我們晉級了沒什麼好講的
Elma avatar
By Elma
at 2011-04-12T16:31
基本上對某些人來講,巴薩贏了就是有乾爹保佑。
會酸的人就是會一直酸。 看開了就好。
Freda avatar
By Freda
at 2011-04-15T05:04
是啊..雖然說這場裁判爭議很大 但我們真的踢的比較好也是事
Enid avatar
By Enid
at 2011-04-17T17:37
實 看某版有些文章很好笑 巴薩每年踢歐冠都被酸乾爹 既然我
們那麼弱 為啥要拋棄自己風格打防反? 一邊酸人都靠乾爹弱
Thomas avatar
By Thomas
at 2011-04-20T06:10
一邊說巴薩技術流太威了 擺防反有啥不對 整個好精神分裂XDD
Daniel avatar
By Daniel
at 2011-04-22T18:43
其實槍手打對攻真的比打防反有威脅跟好看得多 然後槍手的後
Daniel avatar
By Daniel
at 2011-04-25T07:16
衛大家也不是都沒看英超......
Edward Lewis avatar
By Edward Lewis
at 2011-04-27T19:49
文章我當然看的懂啦 我是對你的簽名檔提出一些看法 勿見怪
Daniel avatar
By Daniel
at 2011-04-30T08:22
去年歐冠我是有稍微看一下高光 皮克自討紅牌的防守印象深刻
Faithe avatar
By Faithe
at 2011-05-02T20:55
球離開人才倒就沒有犯規?這什麼鬼邏輯
Daniel avatar
By Daniel
at 2011-05-05T09:28
並沒有人否認巴薩的實力 重點是在於每次關係晉級的比賽
總免不了 這種讓人驚訝的判罰 實在很可惜
Tristan Cohan avatar
By Tristan Cohan
at 2011-05-07T22:01
梅西是已經撥球要橫向移動被迪阿比一個蹬踏 這樣沒犯規?
Bennie avatar
By Bennie
at 2011-05-10T10:35
停兩台大巴開始玩美式足球,難道是巴薩的問題嗎?
Rachel avatar
By Rachel
at 2011-05-12T23:08
每次關係晉級的比賽 總免不了看到WWE 實在很可惜
Callum avatar
By Callum
at 2011-05-15T11:41
簡單來說 只要最後一場 倒向巴薩就OK 也不會被說閒話
Selena avatar
By Selena
at 2011-05-18T00:14
frisk,如果你看不懂這篇文章,直說即可,我們不會笑你
不過如果你看不懂要裝懂硬要發表你自認為很高明的可笑言
論,那接下來就不會那麼有禮貌了。你是怎樣的貨色大家都
清楚,請自重=]
Lauren avatar
By Lauren
at 2011-05-20T12:47
可以不要再來海巡了嗎?
Hardy avatar
By Hardy
at 2011-05-23T01:20
P大真的沒必要浪費時間在他身上
Connor avatar
By Connor
at 2011-05-25T13:53
大師還是回到你的超境發功吧 這邊紅塵俗地可不需要你 ^.<
Dorothy avatar
By Dorothy
at 2011-05-28T02:26
f大可以回英超板繼續開示啦,大家不是都說很中肯嗎,多溫馨
Bennie avatar
By Bennie
at 2011-05-30T14:59
而且這樣那邊的超迷才會高潮啊 這邊可聽不懂你的"高見"啊
Elizabeth avatar
By Elizabeth
at 2011-06-02T03:32
要推這些文可以去某超板推個夠
Oliver avatar
By Oliver
at 2011-06-04T16:05
不知道會不會有人上演申訴群組組長 說巴薩版迫害?
Margaret avatar
By Margaret
at 2011-06-07T04:38
不過也有可能最後變成 群組組長也是乾爹這樣
Sarah avatar
By Sarah
at 2011-06-09T17:11
典型的贏球酸人 輸球檢討別人在酸別人乾爹 請回吧
Ophelia avatar
By Ophelia
at 2011-06-12T05:44
明明兩隊球迷都不是 不知道來這裡開釋什麼的
Quintina avatar
By Quintina
at 2011-06-14T18:17
加油吧!祝福巴薩武運昌隆! @@"
Vanessa avatar
By Vanessa
at 2011-06-17T06:50
恩恩掰掰
Carol avatar
By Carol
at 2011-06-19T19:23
在某超版開示的這麼明快 幹麻來我們這種化外之地傳道呢...唉
Aaliyah avatar
By Aaliyah
at 2011-06-22T07:56
這2場看下來覺得梅西很沒裁判愛耶XD..進球被沒收.點球也不
Noah avatar
By Noah
at 2011-06-24T20:29
給.整隻小腿被踩也活該..
Dinah avatar
By Dinah
at 2011-06-27T09:02
大師慢走不送,有空請不要過來了
Caroline avatar
By Caroline
at 2011-06-29T21:36
被鄉民笑久了大師倒還真以為自己是大師了 連負債論都出來
Thomas avatar
By Thomas
at 2011-07-02T10:09
真的讓我笑了出來 XD 一個平常只看高光的球迷說的話都可以
如此的自以為是 不簡單不簡單 看來超板的造神運動是成功
Edwina avatar
By Edwina
at 2011-07-04T22:42
的 真造出了個自以為神的大師
Kelly avatar
By Kelly
at 2011-07-07T11:15
當大師同隊球迷超可憐,都得一起背黑鍋....
Enid avatar
By Enid
at 2011-07-09T23:48
真的是推樓上....沒事就要負罵名
Edith avatar
By Edith
at 2011-07-12T12:21
我想問一下喔..簽名檔第一個判決問題點是不該判紅牌嗎?
我是覺得點球無誤~~可以再加張黃牌吧
Agatha avatar
By Agatha
at 2011-07-15T00:54
路過單純好奇 第一個連結判罰有啥問題 可以解釋一下嗎?
William avatar
By William
at 2011-07-17T13:27
喔喔 這可不是籃球進算加罰 單純討論規則
Elma avatar
By Elma
at 2011-07-20T02:00
使對方失去明顯進球機會 紅牌(sending-off)
Sierra Rose avatar
By Sierra Rose
at 2011-07-22T14:33
可是對我來說 看重播就是認為普隊是去爭球
而非故意對法布犯規
Mason avatar
By Mason
at 2011-07-25T03:06
或許裁判認為法布有直接進球機會
Anonymous avatar
By Anonymous
at 2011-07-27T15:39
可是普隊也有機會把球清理掉
John avatar
By John
at 2011-07-30T04:12
Puyol根本就沒出腳阿 被判12碼我覺得OK 但紅牌太誇張
Kumar avatar
By Kumar
at 2011-08-01T16:45
可能判黃牌的就是普隊不管球把法布撞倒 但是OG
Tracy avatar
By Tracy
at 2011-08-04T05:18
紅牌跟有沒有出腳關係並不大
David avatar
By David
at 2011-08-06T17:51
沒想到還需要解釋...
Brianna avatar
By Brianna
at 2011-08-09T06:24
1. Puyol 沒有明顯出手或腳的動作 他趕到傳球點時也來不及
Barb Cronin avatar
By Barb Cronin
at 2011-08-11T18:57
做動作
Gary avatar
By Gary
at 2011-08-14T07:30
2. Busacca 當時可是直接給 Puyol 紅牌 之前他連黃牌都沒有
Elizabeth avatar
By Elizabeth
at 2011-08-16T20:03
照相同標準,Koscielny 在禁區對 Pedro 犯規判點球
為什麼連黃牌都沒判? 他之前可是已經有張黃牌在身了
David avatar
By David
at 2011-08-19T08:37
我還是覺得點球無誤~做人要中肯~他確實干擾到射門了~
Megan avatar
By Megan
at 2011-08-21T21:10
完全有機會直接轟門~~爭議點只有紅不紅牌而已吧
Caroline avatar
By Caroline
at 2011-08-24T09:43
在對手必進的射門時 惡意犯規阻擋射門 直接紅牌
Delia avatar
By Delia
at 2011-08-26T22:16
和在禁區持球時 被侵犯的情況不同
Joe avatar
By Joe
at 2011-08-29T10:49
那球也沒有必進阿= = 話說大師不是回家去了嗎
Charlie avatar
By Charlie
at 2011-08-31T23:22
還來啊
Isabella avatar
By Isabella
at 2011-09-03T11:55
好吧 那我們的點球呢?
Liam avatar
By Liam
at 2011-09-06T00:28
每次判決對我們不利我就會想 太好了不用被說乾爹 XDD
不過事實證明好像還是會被無視的 囧~~
Tracy avatar
By Tracy
at 2011-09-08T13:01
不利還是會被說成乾爹給力我們不爭氣沒把握住
Lucy avatar
By Lucy
at 2011-09-11T01:34
諷刺的是那場比賽對我們做出不利判罰的也是布薩卡
Candice avatar
By Candice
at 2011-09-13T14:07
我還以為大家已經跟我一樣習慣了
Edith avatar
By Edith
at 2011-09-16T02:40
判罰不利我就可以說:說好的乾爹呢? XD
Dinah avatar
By Dinah
at 2011-09-18T15:13
本來很悶,結果昨天一連串新聞後,忽然覺得都沒什麼了。Orz
可能不同立場的球迷真的無法站在同個角度想吧。(我們也是)
Isla avatar
By Isla
at 2011-09-21T03:46
希望世界各地的球員都能無風無浪健康踢下去...
昨天日本花滑選手都沒事,已經在內心喊過十萬次好險了。T.T
Xanthe avatar
By Xanthe
at 2011-09-23T16:19
其實也沒什麼 過去十次誤判有八次倒向巴薩 然後巴薩奪冠
Megan avatar
By Megan
at 2011-09-26T04:52
這是我看完這篇文章的心得 其他不利巴薩的誤判 都是錦上添花
Isla avatar
By Isla
at 2011-09-28T17:25
只有去年是一場意外 被大巴士卡住 裁判拿不出紅牌沒用
Suhail Hany avatar
By Suhail Hany
at 2011-10-01T05:58
至於Puyol的紅牌 是你誤解了 裁判發他紅牌 是認定他惡意犯規
並不是我在認定 我也不是讀這篇文章 才說他惡意
Linda avatar
By Linda
at 2011-10-03T18:31
我不覺得他惡意犯規 只是他從後面想用腳卡位 結果夾住射門腳
那個動作 很讓人印象深刻罷了
Catherine avatar
By Catherine
at 2011-10-06T07:04
另外 我覺得戰球迷沒什麼意思 我純粹只想討論裁判和比賽而已
William avatar
By William
at 2011-10-08T19:38
巴薩踢球根本不需要裁判幫忙 看看其他球迷對這場的想法吧
Oscar avatar
By Oscar
at 2011-10-11T08:11
既然樓上已經有定見,那也不必過來宣教了,反正這裡的
球迷跟你所謂「其他球迷」理解不同,何苦多言?
Dorothy avatar
By Dorothy
at 2011-10-13T20:44
本來裁判爭議判決就是輸家叫比較大聲,如此而已
Tom avatar
By Tom
at 2011-10-16T09:17
我本來是不看歐冠的 對這場紅牌也沒什麼意見 但是看到貴版
Isabella avatar
By Isabella
at 2011-10-18T21:50
6887 6888 連續兩篇在講范佩西紅牌是他活該贏得的 還m起來
Rebecca avatar
By Rebecca
at 2011-10-21T10:23
透過裁判判罰得利的一方 還大聲嚷嚷? 算了吧
Yuri avatar
By Yuri
at 2011-10-23T22:56
裁判亂判、誤判 真的很常見 但是得利之後還批別人真的很少見
Agnes avatar
By Agnes
at 2011-10-26T11:29
輸球檢討別人再酸別人 閣下的格調就有比較高??
Sarah avatar
By Sarah
at 2011-10-29T00:02
這裡也有不支持紅牌的人呀,f大也是選擇性忽略吧?
沒注意到板友的每篇心得都會被m嗎,不需要拿這點來吵。
Erin avatar
By Erin
at 2011-10-31T12:35
這邊是隊版 版主要怎麼處理版面上的文章需要閣下同意?
Zenobia avatar
By Zenobia
at 2011-11-03T01:08
另外我不覺得對紅牌沒意見,卻在英超板大談什麼欠債奪冠還錢
的大師有什麼中肯的立場說話。
Adele avatar
By Adele
at 2011-11-05T13:41
frisk可以麻煩你滾出去嗎
Connor avatar
By Connor
at 2011-11-08T02:14
樓上a大,他不是槍迷,這場沒有輸球檢討別人酸別人喔。XD
Edward Lewis avatar
By Edward Lewis
at 2011-11-10T14:47
但是只要英超球隊輸球他就會狂酸阿.....
Christine avatar
By Christine
at 2011-11-13T03:20
我只能慶幸frisk這種貨色不是西甲迷
Steve avatar
By Steve
at 2011-11-15T15:53
真是覺得大部分英超迷真是辛苦了
Olga avatar
By Olga
at 2011-11-18T04:26
槍迷輸球後情緒發言可以理解,f大這種假中立又沒料的正義
Christine avatar
By Christine
at 2011-11-20T16:59
魔人是最可惡的,大家不用浪費時間在他身上啦
Edward Lewis avatar
By Edward Lewis
at 2011-11-23T05:32
操 最討厭這種自以為專業強的業餘球迷
John avatar
By John
at 2011-11-25T18:05
不看又愛發表 就愛亂放屁 要亂放屁請滾英超板吧 那邊多著
愛看你放屁的人
Mia avatar
By Mia
at 2011-11-28T06:39
不然你要回利記板放我也管不著 只是不要再來弄臭這邊了
Daph Bay avatar
By Daph Bay
at 2011-11-30T19:12
各位辛苦了 這張兩秒鐘就拿到的紅牌 浪費大家太多的時間 掰
Daph Bay avatar
By Daph Bay
at 2011-12-03T07:45
P大真有耐性...希望f大別來了,這裡不適合您傳教,迷信和
Aaliyah avatar
By Aaliyah
at 2011-12-05T20:18
專業永遠兜不起來,您還是回去找信眾取暖吧
Callum avatar
By Callum
at 2011-12-08T08:51
拿紅牌還要跟秒數有關係 那以往拿紅牌的球員都要集體翻桌了
Elizabeth avatar
By Elizabeth
at 2011-12-10T21:24
剛剛又反覆看了好幾次RVP紅牌的片段,RVP臉看過去時邊審
早就舉旗了...只能說RVP自己白目
Isla avatar
By Isla
at 2011-12-13T09:57
加上上半場時很多次犯規爭吵都跟RVP有關,在裁判心中早就
黑掉了,好啦說來說去都是乾爹的陰謀^_<
Charlotte avatar
By Charlotte
at 2011-12-15T22:30
夠了啦,多作臆測或如果論是沒意義的,我們也贏下了不是嗎
Jessica avatar
By Jessica
at 2011-12-18T11:03

Fabregas ruled out of Man Utd FA Cup tie

Kyle avatar
By Kyle
at 2011-03-10T21:01
http://bit.ly/fkw1bE 隊長可能禮拜六不能上場... 傷害還真大啊 - ...

Tim Vickery: 大衛-魯伊斯,盧西奧的接班人?

Oliver avatar
By Oliver
at 2011-03-10T20:35
Tim Vickery:大衛-魯伊斯,盧西奧的接班人? 大衛-魯伊斯(David Luiz)能夠成長為俱樂部和國家隊的後防中堅和球場領袖嗎?這名剛 剛被切爾西簽下的巴西小夥子,會成長為下一個盧西奧(Lucio)嗎? 他們之間的確有很多相同點,但也並非完全一樣。 2007年,當時效力於葡萄牙豪門本菲卡的 ...

納尼傷勢比最初預計嚴重 傷口太深導致無法縫合

Kristin avatar
By Kristin
at 2011-03-10T20:22
納尼傷勢比最初預計嚴重 傷口太深導致無法縫合 2011-03-10 10:54:26 來源: 網易體育 http://sports.163.com/11/0310/10/6UPFBURA00051CCL.html 網易體育3月10月報道: 《每日鏡報》透露,納尼的傷勢比最初預計的要嚴重, ...

曼聯官網憶貝斯特最佳球45週年 那刻他一戰封神

James avatar
By James
at 2011-03-10T20:04
曼聯官網憶貝斯特最佳球45週年 那刻他一戰封神 2011-03-10 03:33:05 來源: 網易體育  http://sports.163.com/11/0310/03/6UOM3R2V00051CCL.html 網易體育3月10日報道: 任何球星之所以能稱之為傳奇,都是因為擁有足以 ...

加斯科因自曝一終身遺憾 求弗爵買他被拒

Ida avatar
By Ida
at 2011-03-10T19:57
比魯尼更強天才自曝一終身遺憾 求弗爵買他被拒 2011-03-09 21:41:00 來源: 網易體育 http://sports.163.com/11/0309/21/6UO1V4U600051CCL.html 網易體育3月9日報道: 保羅-加斯科因被認為是英格蘭有史以來天賦最高的天才 ...