波波對林的這一分 - 桌球

※ 引述《edifymyself (自動流浪)》之銘言：
: 標題: [問題] 波波對林的這一分
: 時間: Sun Nov 12 14:41:23 2017
:
:
: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7XYmHFQqdU8
: 在２：２０的地方 球觸網過打到波波的桌子回彈在打到網架字母"D"的位置
: 所以這分應該是波波的吧，打到網架不算二跳
: 但是就算是誤判也不能怪裁判，沒辦法用錄影回放來做判決
: 還有老將撲球真的讓人感動啊
: https://imgur.com/a/X9X42 彈跳前一刻 球已在桌外，碰到網架
:

鬼打牆的一跳二跳，對規則的理解一開始就搞錯方向了

關於一分的運行，以單打為例規則上是

Player A 完成 2.6 -> Player B 完成 2.7 -> A 2.7 -> .....

A 或 B 其中一方不能完成按照這個次序進行時，對方得分 (2.10)


2.2 THE NET ASSEMBLY
2.2.1 The net assembly shall consist of the net, its suspension and
the supporting posts, including the clamps attaching them to the
table.

2.5 DEFINITIONS
2.5.7 A player strikes the ball if he or she touches it in play with
his or her racket, held in the hand, or with his or her racket hand
below the wrist.

2.6 THE SERVICE
2.6.x 這個例子沒有發球問題，有興趣自己看

2.7 THE RETURN
2.7.1 The ball, having been served or returned, shall be struck
so that it touches the opponent's court, either directly or
after touching the net assembly.

2.10 A POINT
2.10.1 Unless the rally is a let, a player shall score a point
2.10.1.1 if an opponent fails to make a correct service;
2.10.1.2 if an opponent fails to make a correct return;
2.10.1.3 if, after he or she has made a service or a return, the
ball touches anything other than the net assembly before being
struck by an opponent;
2.10.1.5 if the ball, after being struck by an opponent, passes
through the net or between the net and the net post or between
the net and playing surface;

2.10.1.x 還有好幾條，和原 PO 問題無關，有興趣自己多看看


這個例子裡，林擊球明確地遵從規則 2.7.1，

(2.7.1) 球拍擊球 -> 觸網 -> 落桌

然後呢，再次碰網、再次碰桌面？網架？

說實話，我看了好幾遍，我不太能確定是碰桌面還是碰網架


所以看 2.10.1.3，如果第二次碰桌面，那麼 anything other
than the net assembly，所以林得分；如果是碰網架，因為之後
波波有成功回擊 (return / 進桌面)，所以波波得分

所以規則非常明確，按規則精神走，重點在於是碰桌面還是碰網架，
這是裁判的權力

以下推文恕我略刪部分



: --