女單FS-LIVE - 花式滑冰 Figure Skating

By Oliver
at 2014-02-21T03:59
at 2014-02-21T03:59
Table of Contents
哈囉各位新版友大家好,
因為有點爭議的結果,讓花滑板湧入了平常10倍以上的人潮。
因為台灣時間已經很晚了,就讓人在異鄉的小弟我來解釋一下這次的結果好了 XD
(我在板上應該不算最資深的,不過冰迷歷史到今年也剛好十年,
技術手冊也讀得滿熟的--所以昨天猜分才會很準 XD,應該算可以講解)
目前女單長曲的詳細打分表已經出來了,
http://www.isuresults.com/results/owg2014/owg14_Ladies_FS_Scores.pdf
05年之後國際滑冰總會改用新制度,
目前分數分成技術分(TES)與表現分(PCS)。
TES
技術分方面,每一個動作(跳、旋轉、步伐)都有基礎分值 (base value,簡稱BV)
這是統一規定好的。
而根據選手的執行水準,可以再給予-3 ~ +3的執行分 (grade of execution, goe)
另外,跳躍方面,如果旋轉周數不足,不足90度以下的會被標 "<",分數會打折扣,
如果不足180度的就會被標"<<",降組 (三轉跳變成兩轉,兩轉變一轉,分數直接跳水)
有些跳躍起跳會規定要用冰刀的內刃或外刃,如果用刃有瑕疵則會被標"e" 一樣扣分
PCS
表現分方面,
以單人滑來說,
分成五個小分(SS,TR,PE,CH,IN),分別代表滑行技巧、銜接、表現執行、編舞、詮釋。
每一個裁判在每一個小分上分別以滿分10分為基礎打分
最後的表現分結果則是依照所有裁判的打分值來計算。
最後的總分則是以TES+PCS來計算。
[此次給分分析]
打開計分表,我們以A和KIM兩人比較,
技術分的BV,其實YUNA就輸將近4分了,
因為YUNA有兩個項目 (StSq, LSp)(step sequence步伐,跟layback spin後仰旋轉)
的定級只有上3級,沒有到4級。
於是唯一有爭議的地方剩下技術分的GOE部分,跟表現分部分。
今天AS技術動作完成的的確很好,GOE分數就我而言沒什麼爭議。
KIM以往的GOE是她分數的重要來源,但這幾年練習少,比賽也少,加上年紀問題,
完成的動作質量的確不如以往。這裡也算是還可以接受。
表現分,大體上KIM的分數都比較高,這點沒有問題,
但是真要說的話,二號裁判給KIM的分數都在7-8之間,
有明顯壓分嫌疑 (跟其他人給KIM的分數一比就很明顯)。
至於AS的表現分,的確炒熱氣氛是有,但是以花式滑冰的打分標準,
這個不得不說灌水是有點誇張。
但是所有裁判都灌成一片,這也只能說是現場地主優勢,氣氛就壓過人了...
表現分的打分,就算是在新制也是很主觀,也是為人詬病的地方。
至於MAO ASADA,她兩個跳都被 "<"打折,
雖然看起來沒有跌倒,但是就是有周數不足的問題。
另外,因為出場順序較前面,表現分自然受到影響,也會稍低一點。
只能說昨天短曲沒有把握好,可惜了...
如果她在最後一組的話,長曲分數應該會比YUNA高沒有問題。
===
總之,歡迎大家加入欣賞花滑的行列 XD
這個新的打分標準可能需要稍微研究一下,
不然如果只看帳面上的有沒有不穩或摔倒可能就會判斷失準。
詳細的規則可以上ISU(國際滑冰聯盟)來看,
有些詳細的規定因為很複雜,包括圈數、秒數、還有很多專有動作名,我就不列了 XD
希望這篇文章可以幫助大家入門,
稍稍看懂「為什麼會是這樣」,還有即使覺得不公平,也至少要知道「不公平在哪裡」。
這樣才能夠在更有共識的基礎上討論滑冰比賽的結果 :)
還有問題的歡迎推文,我相信資深版友都會很樂意回答的,
因為版主常常神隱(XD),就讓小弟我來代替她歡迎大家進入花式滑冰的世界吧 :)!
--
因為有點爭議的結果,讓花滑板湧入了平常10倍以上的人潮。
因為台灣時間已經很晚了,就讓人在異鄉的小弟我來解釋一下這次的結果好了 XD
(我在板上應該不算最資深的,不過冰迷歷史到今年也剛好十年,
技術手冊也讀得滿熟的--所以昨天猜分才會很準 XD,應該算可以講解)
目前女單長曲的詳細打分表已經出來了,
http://www.isuresults.com/results/owg2014/owg14_Ladies_FS_Scores.pdf
05年之後國際滑冰總會改用新制度,
目前分數分成技術分(TES)與表現分(PCS)。
TES
技術分方面,每一個動作(跳、旋轉、步伐)都有基礎分值 (base value,簡稱BV)
這是統一規定好的。
而根據選手的執行水準,可以再給予-3 ~ +3的執行分 (grade of execution, goe)
另外,跳躍方面,如果旋轉周數不足,不足90度以下的會被標 "<",分數會打折扣,
如果不足180度的就會被標"<<",降組 (三轉跳變成兩轉,兩轉變一轉,分數直接跳水)
有些跳躍起跳會規定要用冰刀的內刃或外刃,如果用刃有瑕疵則會被標"e" 一樣扣分
PCS
表現分方面,
以單人滑來說,
分成五個小分(SS,TR,PE,CH,IN),分別代表滑行技巧、銜接、表現執行、編舞、詮釋。
每一個裁判在每一個小分上分別以滿分10分為基礎打分
最後的表現分結果則是依照所有裁判的打分值來計算。
最後的總分則是以TES+PCS來計算。
[此次給分分析]
打開計分表,我們以A和KIM兩人比較,
技術分的BV,其實YUNA就輸將近4分了,
因為YUNA有兩個項目 (StSq, LSp)(step sequence步伐,跟layback spin後仰旋轉)
的定級只有上3級,沒有到4級。
於是唯一有爭議的地方剩下技術分的GOE部分,跟表現分部分。
今天AS技術動作完成的的確很好,GOE分數就我而言沒什麼爭議。
KIM以往的GOE是她分數的重要來源,但這幾年練習少,比賽也少,加上年紀問題,
完成的動作質量的確不如以往。這裡也算是還可以接受。
表現分,大體上KIM的分數都比較高,這點沒有問題,
但是真要說的話,二號裁判給KIM的分數都在7-8之間,
有明顯壓分嫌疑 (跟其他人給KIM的分數一比就很明顯)。
至於AS的表現分,的確炒熱氣氛是有,但是以花式滑冰的打分標準,
這個不得不說灌水是有點誇張。
但是所有裁判都灌成一片,這也只能說是現場地主優勢,氣氛就壓過人了...
表現分的打分,就算是在新制也是很主觀,也是為人詬病的地方。
至於MAO ASADA,她兩個跳都被 "<"打折,
雖然看起來沒有跌倒,但是就是有周數不足的問題。
另外,因為出場順序較前面,表現分自然受到影響,也會稍低一點。
只能說昨天短曲沒有把握好,可惜了...
如果她在最後一組的話,長曲分數應該會比YUNA高沒有問題。
===
總之,歡迎大家加入欣賞花滑的行列 XD
這個新的打分標準可能需要稍微研究一下,
不然如果只看帳面上的有沒有不穩或摔倒可能就會判斷失準。
詳細的規則可以上ISU(國際滑冰聯盟)來看,
有些詳細的規定因為很複雜,包括圈數、秒數、還有很多專有動作名,我就不列了 XD
希望這篇文章可以幫助大家入門,
稍稍看懂「為什麼會是這樣」,還有即使覺得不公平,也至少要知道「不公平在哪裡」。
這樣才能夠在更有共識的基礎上討論滑冰比賽的結果 :)
還有問題的歡迎推文,我相信資深版友都會很樂意回答的,
因為版主常常神隱(XD),就讓小弟我來代替她歡迎大家進入花式滑冰的世界吧 :)!
--
Tags:
花式滑冰
All Comments

By Rachel
at 2014-02-21T18:15
at 2014-02-21T18:15

By Hedy
at 2014-02-22T08:31
at 2014-02-22T08:31

By Tristan Cohan
at 2014-02-22T22:48
at 2014-02-22T22:48

By Poppy
at 2014-02-23T13:04
at 2014-02-23T13:04

By Isabella
at 2014-02-24T03:20
at 2014-02-24T03:20

By Olga
at 2014-02-24T17:36
at 2014-02-24T17:36

By Bethany
at 2014-02-25T07:52
at 2014-02-25T07:52

By Sierra Rose
at 2014-02-25T22:09
at 2014-02-25T22:09

By Kumar
at 2014-02-26T12:25
at 2014-02-26T12:25

By Edward Lewis
at 2014-02-27T02:41
at 2014-02-27T02:41

By Aaliyah
at 2014-02-27T16:57
at 2014-02-27T16:57

By Charlie
at 2014-02-28T07:13
at 2014-02-28T07:13

By Mason
at 2014-02-28T21:29
at 2014-02-28T21:29

By Victoria
at 2014-03-01T11:46
at 2014-03-01T11:46

By Brianna
at 2014-03-02T02:02
at 2014-03-02T02:02

By Andrew
at 2014-03-02T16:18
at 2014-03-02T16:18

By Lydia
at 2014-03-03T06:34
at 2014-03-03T06:34

By Olive
at 2014-03-03T20:50
at 2014-03-03T20:50

By Margaret
at 2014-03-04T11:07
at 2014-03-04T11:07

By Ida
at 2014-03-05T01:23
at 2014-03-05T01:23

By Todd Johnson
at 2014-03-05T15:39
at 2014-03-05T15:39

By Irma
at 2014-03-06T05:55
at 2014-03-06T05:55

By Jacob
at 2014-03-06T20:11
at 2014-03-06T20:11

By Lily
at 2014-03-07T10:27
at 2014-03-07T10:27

By Olivia
at 2014-03-08T00:44
at 2014-03-08T00:44

By Ina
at 2014-03-08T15:00
at 2014-03-08T15:00

By Audriana
at 2014-03-09T05:16
at 2014-03-09T05:16

By Blanche
at 2014-03-09T19:32
at 2014-03-09T19:32

By Andrew
at 2014-03-10T09:48
at 2014-03-10T09:48

By Tom
at 2014-03-11T00:05
at 2014-03-11T00:05

By Elvira
at 2014-03-11T14:21
at 2014-03-11T14:21

By Bennie
at 2014-03-12T04:37
at 2014-03-12T04:37

By Kelly
at 2014-03-12T18:53
at 2014-03-12T18:53

By Joe
at 2014-03-13T09:09
at 2014-03-13T09:09

By Bennie
at 2014-03-13T23:25
at 2014-03-13T23:25

By Robert
at 2014-03-14T13:42
at 2014-03-14T13:42

By Rebecca
at 2014-03-15T03:58
at 2014-03-15T03:58

By Tracy
at 2014-03-15T18:14
at 2014-03-15T18:14

By Ida
at 2014-03-16T08:30
at 2014-03-16T08:30

By Lauren
at 2014-03-16T22:46
at 2014-03-16T22:46

By Daph Bay
at 2014-03-17T13:03
at 2014-03-17T13:03

By Megan
at 2014-03-18T03:19
at 2014-03-18T03:19

By Annie
at 2014-03-18T17:35
at 2014-03-18T17:35

By Jacky
at 2014-03-19T07:51
at 2014-03-19T07:51

By Queena
at 2014-03-19T22:07
at 2014-03-19T22:07

By Jessica
at 2014-03-20T12:24
at 2014-03-20T12:24

By Joseph
at 2014-03-21T02:40
at 2014-03-21T02:40

By Edward Lewis
at 2014-03-21T16:56
at 2014-03-21T16:56

By Bethany
at 2014-03-22T07:12
at 2014-03-22T07:12

By Madame
at 2014-03-22T21:28
at 2014-03-22T21:28

By Hazel
at 2014-03-23T11:44
at 2014-03-23T11:44

By Leila
at 2014-03-24T02:01
at 2014-03-24T02:01

By Hamiltion
at 2014-03-24T16:17
at 2014-03-24T16:17

By Ingrid
at 2014-03-25T06:33
at 2014-03-25T06:33

By Hedda
at 2014-03-25T20:49
at 2014-03-25T20:49

By Wallis
at 2014-03-26T11:05
at 2014-03-26T11:05

By Selena
at 2014-03-27T01:22
at 2014-03-27T01:22

By James
at 2014-03-27T15:38
at 2014-03-27T15:38

By Agatha
at 2014-03-28T05:54
at 2014-03-28T05:54

By Lydia
at 2014-03-28T20:10
at 2014-03-28T20:10

By Noah
at 2014-03-29T10:26
at 2014-03-29T10:26

By Candice
at 2014-03-30T00:42
at 2014-03-30T00:42

By Edith
at 2014-03-30T14:59
at 2014-03-30T14:59

By Barb Cronin
at 2014-03-31T05:15
at 2014-03-31T05:15

By Sarah
at 2014-03-31T19:31
at 2014-03-31T19:31

By Donna
at 2014-04-01T09:47
at 2014-04-01T09:47

By Thomas
at 2014-04-02T00:03
at 2014-04-02T00:03

By Franklin
at 2014-04-02T14:20
at 2014-04-02T14:20

By Thomas
at 2014-04-03T04:36
at 2014-04-03T04:36

By Puput
at 2014-04-03T18:52
at 2014-04-03T18:52

By Rachel
at 2014-04-04T09:08
at 2014-04-04T09:08

By Ursula
at 2014-04-04T23:24
at 2014-04-04T23:24

By Damian
at 2014-04-05T13:40
at 2014-04-05T13:40

By Queena
at 2014-04-06T03:57
at 2014-04-06T03:57

By Eden
at 2014-04-06T18:13
at 2014-04-06T18:13

By Ethan
at 2014-04-07T08:29
at 2014-04-07T08:29

By Irma
at 2014-04-07T22:45
at 2014-04-07T22:45

By Linda
at 2014-04-08T13:01
at 2014-04-08T13:01

By Agnes
at 2014-04-09T03:18
at 2014-04-09T03:18

By Cara
at 2014-04-09T17:34
at 2014-04-09T17:34

By Caitlin
at 2014-04-10T07:50
at 2014-04-10T07:50

By Ida
at 2014-04-10T22:06
at 2014-04-10T22:06

By Regina
at 2014-04-11T12:22
at 2014-04-11T12:22

By Adele
at 2014-04-12T02:38
at 2014-04-12T02:38

By Dora
at 2014-04-12T16:55
at 2014-04-12T16:55

By Kama
at 2014-04-13T07:11
at 2014-04-13T07:11

By Necoo
at 2014-04-13T21:27
at 2014-04-13T21:27

By Olga
at 2014-04-14T11:43
at 2014-04-14T11:43

By Donna
at 2014-04-15T01:59
at 2014-04-15T01:59

By David
at 2014-04-15T16:16
at 2014-04-15T16:16

By Wallis
at 2014-04-16T06:32
at 2014-04-16T06:32

By Xanthe
at 2014-04-16T20:48
at 2014-04-16T20:48

By Lauren
at 2014-04-17T11:04
at 2014-04-17T11:04

By Suhail Hany
at 2014-04-18T01:20
at 2014-04-18T01:20

By Christine
at 2014-04-18T15:36
at 2014-04-18T15:36

By Una
at 2014-04-19T05:53
at 2014-04-19T05:53

By Eden
at 2014-04-19T20:09
at 2014-04-19T20:09

By Doris
at 2014-04-20T10:25
at 2014-04-20T10:25

By Edward Lewis
at 2014-04-21T00:41
at 2014-04-21T00:41

By Connor
at 2014-04-21T14:57
at 2014-04-21T14:57

By Hardy
at 2014-04-22T05:14
at 2014-04-22T05:14

By Wallis
at 2014-04-22T19:30
at 2014-04-22T19:30

By Iris
at 2014-04-23T09:46
at 2014-04-23T09:46

By Charlotte
at 2014-04-24T00:02
at 2014-04-24T00:02

By Daniel
at 2014-04-24T14:18
at 2014-04-24T14:18

By Olive
at 2014-04-25T04:35
at 2014-04-25T04:35

By Jake
at 2014-04-25T18:51
at 2014-04-25T18:51

By Frederic
at 2014-04-26T09:07
at 2014-04-26T09:07

By Christine
at 2014-04-26T23:23
at 2014-04-26T23:23

By Anthony
at 2014-04-27T13:39
at 2014-04-27T13:39

By John
at 2014-04-28T03:55
at 2014-04-28T03:55

By Dorothy
at 2014-04-28T18:12
at 2014-04-28T18:12

By Necoo
at 2014-04-29T08:28
at 2014-04-29T08:28

By Brianna
at 2014-04-29T22:44
at 2014-04-29T22:44

By Tracy
at 2014-04-30T13:00
at 2014-04-30T13:00

By Dorothy
at 2014-05-01T03:16
at 2014-05-01T03:16

By Lydia
at 2014-05-01T17:33
at 2014-05-01T17:33

By Valerie
at 2014-05-02T07:49
at 2014-05-02T07:49

By Callum
at 2014-05-02T22:05
at 2014-05-02T22:05

By Isla
at 2014-05-03T12:21
at 2014-05-03T12:21

By Hedy
at 2014-05-04T02:37
at 2014-05-04T02:37

By Elizabeth
at 2014-05-04T16:53
at 2014-05-04T16:53

By Damian
at 2014-05-05T07:10
at 2014-05-05T07:10

By Hedy
at 2014-05-05T21:26
at 2014-05-05T21:26

By Elvira
at 2014-05-06T11:42
at 2014-05-06T11:42

By Caroline
at 2014-05-07T01:58
at 2014-05-07T01:58

By Dora
at 2014-05-07T16:14
at 2014-05-07T16:14

By Cara
at 2014-05-08T06:31
at 2014-05-08T06:31

By George
at 2014-05-08T20:47
at 2014-05-08T20:47

By Genevieve
at 2014-05-09T11:03
at 2014-05-09T11:03

By Lily
at 2014-05-10T01:19
at 2014-05-10T01:19

By Hedda
at 2014-05-10T15:35
at 2014-05-10T15:35

By Olive
at 2014-05-11T05:51
at 2014-05-11T05:51

By Bennie
at 2014-05-11T20:08
at 2014-05-11T20:08

By Michael
at 2014-05-12T10:24
at 2014-05-12T10:24

By Oscar
at 2014-05-13T00:40
at 2014-05-13T00:40

By George
at 2014-05-13T14:56
at 2014-05-13T14:56

By Erin
at 2014-05-14T05:12
at 2014-05-14T05:12

By Adele
at 2014-05-14T19:29
at 2014-05-14T19:29

By Lucy
at 2014-05-15T09:45
at 2014-05-15T09:45

By Zanna
at 2014-05-16T00:01
at 2014-05-16T00:01

By Dorothy
at 2014-05-16T14:17
at 2014-05-16T14:17

By Odelette
at 2014-05-17T04:33
at 2014-05-17T04:33

By Erin
at 2014-05-17T18:49
at 2014-05-17T18:49

By Agnes
at 2014-05-18T09:06
at 2014-05-18T09:06

By Connor
at 2014-05-18T23:22
at 2014-05-18T23:22

By Agnes
at 2014-05-19T13:38
at 2014-05-19T13:38

By Joseph
at 2014-05-20T03:54
at 2014-05-20T03:54

By Dorothy
at 2014-05-20T18:10
at 2014-05-20T18:10

By Belly
at 2014-05-21T08:27
at 2014-05-21T08:27

By Jacob
at 2014-05-21T22:43
at 2014-05-21T22:43

By Xanthe
at 2014-05-22T12:59
at 2014-05-22T12:59

By Agatha
at 2014-05-23T03:15
at 2014-05-23T03:15

By Elizabeth
at 2014-05-23T17:31
at 2014-05-23T17:31

By Leila
at 2014-05-24T07:47
at 2014-05-24T07:47

By Emily
at 2014-05-24T22:04
at 2014-05-24T22:04

By Tristan Cohan
at 2014-05-25T12:20
at 2014-05-25T12:20

By Christine
at 2014-05-26T02:36
at 2014-05-26T02:36

By Ina
at 2014-05-26T16:52
at 2014-05-26T16:52

By Leila
at 2014-05-27T07:08
at 2014-05-27T07:08

By Carol
at 2014-05-27T21:25
at 2014-05-27T21:25
Related Posts
詳訊:冬奧花滑女單短節目 金妍兒獲74.92

By Ingrid
at 2014-02-20T04:34
at 2014-02-20T04:34
愛上jeremy abbott

By Susan
at 2014-02-18T14:03
at 2014-02-18T14:03
冬奧冰舞SD&FD

By Eden
at 2014-02-16T22:55
at 2014-02-16T22:55
索契冬奧後日本男子選手訪問

By Ursula
at 2014-02-16T00:35
at 2014-02-16T00:35
冬季奧運花式滑冰轉播在台北要到哪裡看

By Suhail Hany
at 2014-02-15T13:24
at 2014-02-15T13:24